Examining Green Transition energy missteps worldwide to shape India’s sustainable future.

As the world shifts toward renewable energy, nations have faced significant hurdles in their green transitions. While clean energy is essential to combating climate change, failures in planning, policy, and execution have hindered progress in several countries. India, aiming to be a global sustainability leader, can learn valuable lessons from these missteps to avoid similar setbacks.

Here, we examine five major green transition failures from around the world and explore what India can learn from them.

1. Germany’s Struggles with the Energiewende

What Went Wrong?

Germany’s ambitious energy transition plan, Energiewende, aimed to phase out nuclear power while rapidly expanding renewables. However, the policy led to skyrocketing consumer electricity prices due to high solar and wind energy subsidies. Many households, especially renters, bore the burden of rising costs while wealthier property owners benefited from incentives. The transition was also disrupted by geopolitical events, such as the Ukraine war, which increased reliance on costly liquefied natural gas (LNG) imports after the Russian gas supply was cut off.

Lessons for India:

• Ensure that the cost of energy transition is equitably distributed among consumers.
• Avoid over-reliance on expensive energy imports by developing domestic renewable energy manufacturing.
• Strengthen grid infrastructure to support intermittent renewable sources efficiently.

(Source: Jacobin)

2. California’s Overdependence on Solar and Wind

What Went Wrong?

California aggressively pursued renewable energy but failed to address grid reliability. The state’s overreliance on solar and wind, without adequate energy storage or baseload power sources, led to rolling blackouts during heatwaves when demand surged, but renewable supply dipped. Wildfires also damaged power infrastructure, exacerbating energy shortages.

Lessons for India:

• Invest in energy storage solutions, like battery systems, to manage intermittent renewable supply.
• Maintain a diverse energy mix, including solar, wind, hydro, and nuclear, to ensure grid stability.
• Enhance climate-resilient power infrastructure to withstand extreme weather conditions.

(Source: Resilience)

3. Spain’s Renewable Energy Bubble & Financial Collapse

What Went Wrong?

Spain launched aggressive incentives for renewable energy, leading to a solar power investment boom. However, the government cut subsidies abruptly when it could no longer afford them, causing massive financial losses for investors and a collapse in new renewable energy projects.

Lessons for India:

• Ensure that renewable energy incentives are financially sustainable to avoid policy reversals.
• Provide long-term investment security for clean energy developers to maintain confidence in the market.
• Focus on gradual, steady policy implementation rather than rapid, unsustainable expansion.

(Source: Clean Energy Wire)

4. The UK’s Offshore Wind Setbacks

What Went Wrong?

The UK, a leader in offshore wind, faced challenges when several offshore wind projects were canceled due to rising material and financing costs. Government policies failed to account for inflation and supply chain disruptions, making projects economically unviable despite initial optimism.

Lessons for India:

• Plan for cost escalations and inflation in renewable energy projects.
• Develop strong domestic supply chains for clean energy components to reduce import reliance.
• Implement long-term price stabilization mechanisms for large-scale renewable projects.

(Source: The Guardian)

5. South Africa’s Coal-to-Renewable Transition Failure

What Went Wrong?

South Africa aimed to transition from coal to renewables but neglected investment in grid modernization, leading to frequent power shortages and rolling blackouts. Political and financial challenges delayed critical infrastructure upgrades, slowing the transition.

Lessons for India:

• Strengthen grid infrastructure before phasing out fossil fuels.
• Address political and bureaucratic hurdles to ensure the efficient execution of green policies.
• Ensure a just transition for coal-dependent communities by reskilling workers for green jobs.

(Source: The Economist)

Key Takeaways for India

1. Ensure Affordable Green Energy: Avoid policies that increase consumer energy costs disproportionately.
2. Invest in Grid Infrastructure: A robust and modernized grid is essential for integrating renewables.
3. Encourage Sustainable Incentives: Government subsidies should be financially viable and long-term.
4. Support Local Supply Chains: Reduce import dependence by fostering domestic clean energy manufacturing.
5. Plan for Economic & Geopolitical Risks: Factor in price fluctuations and geopolitical disruptions in policy planning.

India is at a critical juncture in its green transition journey. By learning from global mistakes, India can develop a more resilient, inclusive, and sustainable clean energy future. The key is strategic planning, financial prudence, and strong policy execution to ensure a successful and equitable energy transition for all.

For more inspiring Blogs,  click here.